As data centres continue to evolve, the choice of battery technology is no longer just a technical decision but it directly impacts operational efficiency, total cost of ownership (TCO), physical footprint, and sustainability. Two dominant technologies have emerged in this space: VRLA (Valve Regulated Lead Acid) batteries and Lithium ion batteries. Each comes with its own set of advantages and trade-offs, making it essential to understand which option aligns best with your data centre’s needs.
This guide explores the practical considerations for choosing between VRLA and Lithium-ion, helping planners make informed decisions that balance cost, performance, and future-readiness.
Why Battery Choice Matters
The battery system is the backbone of any uninterrupted power supply (UPS) infrastructure. While power outages are rare, the consequences can be catastrophic, downtime can impact revenue, client trust, and service-level agreements.
Lithium-ion batteries have become a major trend in the UPS industry, offering strong advantages such as longer lifespan, faster charging, and a smaller footprint. However, they also come with a higher upfront cost and are not suitable for every situation. Some regions and industries still face regulations or safety restrictions that limit the use of Lithium-ion batteries, which means businesses must evaluate local compliance and operational needs before choosing this technology.
Understanding the trade-offs between these technologies is critical for technical planners, engineers, and operational teams who need to make decisions grounded in both technical performance and financial prudence.
Key Comparison Areas
1. Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)
VRLA batteries remain more budget-friendly upfront, making them suitable for organisations with limited capital. However, their shorter lifespan and regular maintenance can increase long-term costs.
Lithium-ion batteries require a higher initial investment, but their longer service life, lower maintenance needs, and better efficiency can reduce overall TCO in the long run.
2. Footprint and Space Efficiency
VRLA batteries are bulkier and require more space, which is still acceptable for facilities that have room to spare.
Lithium-ion batteries offer higher energy density, allowing the same capacity in a smaller footprint—useful for space-restricted data centres.
3. Maintenance Requirements
VRLA batteries need frequent inspections, temperature checks, and periodic replacements, making them more hands-on.
Lithium-ion batteries generally require less routine maintenance, supported by advanced monitoring systems, which helps reduce operational workload.
4. Charging and Performance Characteristics
VRLA batteries are reliable but have slower charging times and can degrade faster with deep discharge cycles.
Lithium-ion batteries charge faster and deliver a more stable voltage profile. However, some regions and industries have regulatory restrictions, so suitability may vary.
5. Environmental Considerations
VRLA batteries are recyclable but contain lead, requiring careful handling and disposal.
Lithium-ion batteries produce fewer hazardous by-products and support cleaner recycling, though the availability of recycling facilities can differ by country.
Side by Side Comparison Between VRLA & Lithium-ion
| Feature | VRLA | Lithium-ion |
| Upfront Cost | Cost-efficient initial investment | Higher |
| Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) | Moderate to high due to maintenance & replacement | Lower over lifespan |
| Lifespan | 3-7 years | 10-15 years or more |
| Footprint / Energy Density | Larger footprint per kWh | Smaller, high energy density |
| Maintenance | Requires regular checks and temperature control | Minimal maintenance required |
| Charging Time | Standard, sensitive to deep discharge | Fast, stable voltage |
| Safety | Mature, well-understood | Advanced safety features, thermal management needed |
| Environmental Impact | Contains lead, needs careful disposal | More recyclable, less hazardous by-product |
This table above highlights that the choice isn’t purely about cost, it’s about aligning technical performance, operational needs, and strategic goals.
Making the Decision
Choosing the right battery technology requires a holistic view:
- Assess your operational needs: Consider uptime requirements, redundancy plans, and power density.
- Compare lifecycle costs: Look beyond upfront expenditure to total cost of ownership over the expected lifespan.
- Consider space constraints: Evaluate footprint, rack availability, and facility layout.
- Factor maintenance capabilities: Determine how much operational time and resources can be dedicated to battery upkeep.
- Evaluate sustainability priorities: Account for environmental impact and recycling considerations.
No single technology is universally “better.” Instead, the right choice is informed by how each battery type aligns with your data centre’s current requirements and future strategy.
Conclusion
Selecting the right battery technology for a data centre requires careful evaluation of multiple factors. VRLA batteries provide a reliable, lower-cost option with established maintenance practices, while Lithium-ion batteries offer higher energy density, longer lifespan, and faster, more efficient charging.
Overall, this in-depth comparison of the two battery technologies highlights the differences in total cost of ownership (TCO), physical footprint, and charging requirements, giving readers the insights needed to make an informed decision for their data centre’s future.
Find more about:
